#ArunaShanbaug – Another Chapter Closed Without a Pinch of Remorse or Regret

Aruna Shanbaug

Who was she? Just another human being whom I have never met. Were we related to each other? No. Not at all. Do I feel for her? Yes. She never got justice. I have always felt miserable imagining what if I were in her situation. Or a loved one was. A simple eve-teasing episode leaves you disturbed for days. Then what must be the condition of people who suffer so much. Even the thought gives me goosebumps. Oh! But then she was brain dead. Right? Which means just a pound of flesh. Should her death affect me? Oh, come on! It’s just another “case” that is closed. Or is it? In any case, her death today on the 18th of March, 2015 is an occasion for celebration. Isn’t it?   Aruna1 You read that right. In her last few minutes of ‘being alive’, she helped the wretched Sohan Lal Valmiki celebrate. Celebrate what? Celebrate his revenge. Celebrate his ruthlessness. Celebrate his brutality. Celebrate his animal instincts. When her journalist/author friend Pinki Virani lost her plea for euthanasia, she helped the doctors and nurses of KEM hospital celebrate it as her rebirth and a reward for their unconditional love and care. And today when she died, she has helped humanity celebrate it with open eyes. BMC which had plans of moving her out of the hospital to free the bed that she was occupying has a reason to celebrate. Isn’t it? All of us have a reason to celebrate. For she fought for each of us even in her vegetative state. As Pinki Virani said, “Because of this woman who has never received justice, no other person in a similar position will have to suffer for more than three and a half-decades.” [Source: Wikipedia]

42 years

How long is that? Do we know. I’m just three and a half decades old. And that itself seems like eternity. This woman suffered for 42 long years. All this while her attacker continues to live amongst us. I don’t know if curses work. But if they do, I wish that entire humanity curses him. He should rot and continue to live. He should suffer and remember her helpless face every second. He should pay for his sins.

I had read this piece by Telegraph immediately after it was published in March 2011. I wish I hadn’t. I read it again today. I wish I hadn’t. How many lives are affected by a single person’s sins…
I was the first one to find Aruna in the empty operation theatre in this hospital’s basement after she had been raped and brutally assaulted by that animal Sohan Lal (Valmiki). She was sitting, leaning against a stool with a dog-chain around her neck. There was blood around her. I ran out and brought the matron. As soon as she saw matron Bellimal, her eyes welled up and tears streamed down her face. She tried to say something but could not… only her lips moved. And then, slowly she lost consciousness,” remembers Pramila Kushe.
She survived. But how? I wish she had survived to describe the assault and get the monster tried for rape. And then I think it was better this way. At least she doesn’t know anything. She doesn’t realize anything. She doesn’t see anything. She doesn’t feel anything. Who gets punished for rape (however brutal) in India?
Pinki Virani murdabad.. Pinki Virani ke liye iccha maut (mercy killing)… Aruna Shanbaug zindabad.
Was Pinki Virani wrong in pleading for mercy killing for Aruna? I’m no expert in human rights. But I feel she did what she thought was right. And she did it with all her heart and without any bad intentions.
Was the Supreme Court wrong? It wasn’t. I do believe that crimes happen in every part of the world. But, in a country like India, where trials upon trials and delayed dates ensure complete security to criminals, a judgement on mercy killing was indeed impossible. People would have used it for their benefit without a second thought for money and power.
So thorough was the care she got over the four decades that she was bed-ridden, that Ms Shanbaug did not get bed sores, a fact noted by the Supreme Court in its landmark judgement of 2011, rejecting a petition to stop force feeding her. [Source: NDTV]
Were the nurses wrong in celebrating the Supreme Court verdict? I don’t know. We all would have wanted the same if it was one of our loved ones. Survive as long as they can, in whatever state.
As I read this post from Firstpost this morning, somehow I was happy. She is finally in a better place.

Aruna Shanbaug passes away: A unbearable agony and injustice comes to an end

Related articles on the web:


12 Replies to “#ArunaShanbaug – Another Chapter Closed Without a Pinch of Remorse or Regret”

  1. I have read her story so many times, but I can never decide the wrong and right. I think for these many years, she was being loved by so many people who took care of her selflessly. As you said, even I am happy, she is finally in a better place.

    May she rest in peace.

    1. The only wrong-doer in her story it seems was the ward boy. Everyone else including the Supreme Court have been thinking about her only. I just wish she indeed wasn’t aware of what she had gone through. If she was aware of it, the sinner has been committing the crime every single minute for all these years. And we have all been a part of it. May she find peace in her heavenly abode.

  2. I can’t imagine what she must have gone through! What we did to her!

    I feel ashamed that we failed her…Sometimes I think what could we have done anyways?

    Sometimes I think the only thing to do is kill the people responsible for this…Am I wrong?

    1. You’re not wrong. My blood boils every time I read about such a case. But at the end of it all I know that I’m not capable of helping them as an individual. What is required is collective conscience and speedy trials and sentencing. Without these, all our words are meaningless.

  3. Every time I read about Aruna, I feel like killing thatBa*****! Please pardon me Rekha…but can’t help it. And I can’t even imagine that actually the man was not accused with not a rape case, but only assault and attempt to murder. The reason why he was not charged with a rape case was a sheer mockery- it said, “The rape was not mentioned in the report in order to protect the modesty and honour of the woman.” !!

  4. Aruna finally reached the place she deserved to be. When I read the Firstpost article, it made me feel that there was a personal agenda in keeping Aruna alive. She was surviving because of the people who were looking after her but what were their intentions? She was a case for all of them and that makes me sad. There was success in keeping her alive. What was done to her should have been brought to light and that ward boy should have been punished but what about Aruna? She wasn’t even allowed to die. Being in that vegetative state was a torture and Euthanasia would have been the answer in my mind.

  5. A heart rending story , it truly was. A story of injustice, if ever there was one. One really questions whether justice could ever have been served in this case, for her assaulter didnt give her death but robbed her life, which was far worse than death could have been.

This space thrives on your comments. Bring it on!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s